Hot air engine, developed and patented by Traian Vuia, a Romanian performance for 21st century
Keywords:Carnot, Stirling, Ericsson, Joule, Brayton, engines, almost perfect thermodynamic engines Vuia and Pomojnicu, engines with external combustion, isothermate compression and expansion, isentropic, adiabatic, isodiabatic heat release and receipt, regenerator, recuperator
After thoroughly researching data from national archives, libraries, and important technical studies from Romania and abroad, I concluded that the hot air and closed-circuit engine built, tested, and patented by Romanian engineer Traian Vuia (1872–1950), is superior in its thermodynamic performances to similar engines investigated today. For this engine, almost as perfect thermodynamic Carnot engine, Traian Vuia has achieved ten (10) patents, during 1908-1916 years. Therefore, this engine unjustified forgotten or ignored over a century should be considered a wealth, which belongs (inter) national technical heritage. It represents a great challenge to bring this engine back to the scientific and industrial circuit and, in order to do so, this paper clarifies the following issues: • How evolved over time thermal cycling of different engines, as target perfect thermodynamic engine Carnot; • Which was the thermal process used at Vuia engine for isothermation of compression and expansion; • Today “isodiabate heat release and receipt” at Vuia engine can be qualified as an isentropic process for ideal conditions or adiabatic process for real conditions, with irreversibility, or others; • Which device used Traian Vuia for “isodiabate heat release and receipt”; • Which is the construction and operation of Vuia engine; • If thermal cycle and engine Vuia has been recognized internationally.
CAYLEY, George, Engine for affording mechanical power from air expanded by heat, Letter from September 25, 1807, addressed to Nicholson.
STIRLING, Robert, Air engine, Patent applied in 1816.
ERICSSON, John, Air engines, Patent GB 6409, published in 1833.
JOULE, James Prescott, On the air-engine, Lit. and Phil. Soc. Manchester&c., read before the Royal Society, June 1851, published as: JOULE, J.P., THOMSON, W., On the air-engine, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 142, pp. 65-82, 1852.
BRAYTON, George, Improvement in a gas-engine, patent US 125,166, published on April 2, 1872, further improved by patent US 151,468, Gas-Engine, published on June 2, 1877.
CARNOT, Sady, Reflections on the motive power of heat, Chez Bacheller (bookstore), 1824.
MIHALCEA, Dumitru, Pomojnicu-Chrisoghilos engine, a contemporary version of a Stirling engine type, isothermated (in Romanian language: Motorul Pomojnicu-Chrisoghilos, o varianta contemporana a unui motor de tip Stirling, izotermat), Editura MidoPrint, Cluj Napoca, Romania, 2013.
WALKER, G., Stirling engines, Clarenden Press, Oxford, 1980.
MARTINI, W.R., Stirling engine design manual, NASA CR-168088, 1983.
FINKELSTEIN, T., ORGAN, A.J, Air engines, Professional Engineering Publishing, London, and Bury St. Edmunds, 2001.
The Stirling Engine, Webpage: http://www.mpoweruk.com/stirling_engine.htm, accessed 2018.
MIHALCEA, Dumitru, Engines Vuia, Ericsson, Joule, Brayton, confusion, duplication or novelty (in Romanian: Motoarele Vuia, Ericsson, Joule, Brayton, confuzie, paralelism sau noutate), Manuscript, Cluj Napoca, Romania, 2016.
DIESEL, Rudolf, Theory and construction of a rational heat motor, E. & F.N. Spon, 1894.
DIESEL, Rudolf, Verbrennungskraftmaschinen, Patent no. DRP67207, published in Berlin on February 23, 1893.
VUIA, Traian, Hot-air engine with closed circuit, Patent US 1,169,308, applied on January 6, 1909, published on January 25, 1916
VUIA, Traian, An improved system of hot air engine with closed circuit, Patent GB 27,033, applied on December 12, 1908.
ERICSSON, John, The Caloric Engine, Chap. XXX, in Contributions to the Centennial Exhibition, The Nation Press, New York. 1876.
STOUFFS, Pascal, Le moteur d’Ericsson, un moyen de valorisation de l’énergie thermique à réhabiliter?, Termotehnica, VI, 2, pp. 37-42, 2002, and also: Entropie, 38, 241, pp. 26-32, 2002.
FULA, Alejandro, STOUFFS, Pascal, SIERRA, Fabio, In-cylinder heat transfer in an Ericsson engine prototype, Renewable Energy and Power Quality Journal, 11, paper 594, pp. 1260-1265, 2013.
UNWIN, W.C., On the development and transmission of power from central stations, chap. IX The transmission of power by compressed air, Longmans, Green, and Co., New York, 1894.
ERICSSON, John, Engine for producing motive power – improvement in air engine, Patent US 8,841, published in 1851.
ERICSSON, John, Air engine, Patent US 431,729, published in 1890.
ERICSSON, John, Air engine, Patent US 226,052, published on March 30, 1880.
CHURCH, W.C., The life of John Ericsson, C. Scribner’s Sons, New York, 1906.
RIDER, Alexander K., Hot air engine, Patent GB 3404, published in 1875.
SIER, Robert, Hot air caloric and Stirling engines: A history, Vol. 1, L.A. Mair, 1999.
FRANCHOT, L., Nouvelle machine à air, Comptes Rendus des Séances de l’Académie des Sciences, 11, pp. 235-237, p. 236, 1840.
WALKER, Graham, Cryocoolers: Part 1: Fundamentals, Springer Science + Business Media,New York, 1983
VUIA, Trajan, Moteur à air chaud à cycle fermé, Brevet d’invention BE 205.058, applied on January 6, 1908, accepted on January 31, 1908, and Moteur à air chaud à cycle fermé, Brevet de perfectionnement BE 211.606 pour Brevet principal BE 205.058, applied on October 30, 1908, accepted on November 16, 1908.
VUIA, Trajan, Moteur à air chaud à cycle fermé, Brevet d’invention FR 395.754, applied on October 28, 1908, accepted on March 17, 1909.
VUIA, Trajan, Heisluftmaschinenanlage, Patent CH 48145, applied on December 9, 1908, accepted on September 16, 1910.
VUIA, Trajan, Hot-air engine with closed circuit, application dossier Patent US 1,169,308, 1909, National Archives at Kansas City.
POMOJNICU, Ion, Induced isothermation (in Romanian: Izotermarea indusa), Manuscript, 2015.
TÖRÖK, Arpad, PETRESCU, Stoian, POPESCU, Gheorghe, FEIDT, Michel, Isothermal compressors and expanders, Termotehnica, XVI, 2, pp. 51-58, 2012.
NICHOL, John Pringle, A Cyclopædia of the Physical Sciences, pp. 423-424, London and Glasgow Richard Griffin and Co, Publishers to the University of Glasgow, 1860.
Adiabatic Process, Webpage accessed 2018: https://www.princeton.edu/~achaney/tmve/wiki100k/docs/Adiabatic_process.html
Isentropic processes in thermodynamic systems, Webpage accessed 2018: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isentropic_process#Isentropic_processes_in_thermodynamic_systems
MAHKAMOV, K., Design improvements to a biomass Stirling engine using mathematical analysis and 3D CFD modeling, ASME Journal of Energy Resources Technology, 128, 3, pp. 203-215, 2006.
Building a replica of the John Ericsson Steam Fire Engine, Webpage accessed 2018: http://www.brandhistoriska.org/english/je_angsp_e.html
KOLIN, Ivo, The evolution of the heat engines, 2nd edition, Morya Press, USA, 1998, Longmans, London, 1972.
THOMSON, William (Lord Kelvin), An account of Carnot’s theory, Transactions of the Edinburgh Royal Society, XIV, 1849, Annales de Chimie, XXXV, 1852.
MIHALCEA, Dumitru, Traian Vuia - Inventor of the hot air engine with closed circuit (in Romanian language: Traian Vuia - Inventatorul motorului cu aer cald si circuit inchis), Cluj Napoca, 2017.
MIHALCEA, Dumitru, Traian Vuia - Integrity of inventions claimed for hot air engine with closed circuit engine (in Romanian language: Traian Vuia - Integrala inventiilor revendicate pentru motorul cu aer cald si circuit inchis), Cluj Napoca, 2016.
MIHALCEA, Dumitru, Traian Vuia – Study for rebuilding the hot air and closed-circuit engine, (in Romanian language: Traian Vuia – Studiu pentru reconstruirea motorului Vuia, cu aer cald si circuit inchis), Cluj Napoca, 2017.
Copyright (c) 2020 The Romanian Journal of Technical Sciences. Applied Mechanics.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.